Charles Darwin — Role in the Theory of Natural Selection

There are 4 species of birds on a small island. For a completely realistic but unknown reason, the only food left on the island is small insects. Which of the following birds would most likely be favored by natural selection?

1. Image sources:
2. CC0, via maxpixel.net
3. By: byrev CC0, via pixabay.com
4. By: Charles J Sharp CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
5. CC0, via maxpixel.net